The Quick Answer
Yes. A home can sell before it ever reaches the open market—and in Birmingham and Bloomfield Hills, it happens more often than many homeowners realize.
But just because you can sell before listing doesn't necessarily mean you should.
The real question is whether the convenience and certainty of an early offer outweigh what you might gain by exposing your home to the full market.
How Does a Home Sell Before It’s Listed?
Sometimes a Realtor already knows a buyer looking for exactly the type of home you're preparing to sell. Other times, buyers hear about a property while it's being prepared for market or during a Coming Soon period.
And sometimes a seller deliberately chooses a private or off-market sale because privacy, timing or convenience matters more than having dozens of buyers through the house.
There isn't one right way to sell.
The Offer Before the For-Sale Sign
Let's say you're preparing your Birmingham home for market and a buyer makes a very strong offer before it is publicly listed.
It might be a great offer.
But there's another question worth asking:
How do you know it's the best offer if the rest of the market never had the opportunity to compete?
That's where strategy matters.
An early offer can eliminate showings, open houses and uncertainty. For the right seller—and the right offer—that may have real value.
On the other hand, broad market exposure can create competition and help establish what buyers are actually willing to pay for your home.
The buyer you already know about may be the best buyer.
Or the best buyer may be someone you haven't met yet.
Birmingham & Bloomfield Hills Sellers Have Options
Our local market makes this conversation particularly interesting.
Through June, listings taken in Birmingham and Bloomfield were up 34% year-to-date, while closed sales were up 70% compared with the same period in 2025.
So while we're hearing plenty about increasing inventory, that's only part of the story. Homes are also selling.
For sellers, that means the decision isn't simply Should I list?
It's:
What selling strategy gives my particular home the best opportunity?
That answer may be different for a beautifully renovated home in a highly competitive neighborhood than it is for a seller who prioritizes privacy, convenience or a very specific timeline.
When Might an Off-Market Sale Make Sense?
An off-market or pre-market offer may be worth considering when:
- Privacy is especially important.
- You want to avoid extensive showings.
- Timing or convenience is a priority.
- A buyer is offering unusually attractive price and terms.
- Certainty is more valuable to you than testing the market.
- The offer makes sense when compared with recent sales and current competition.
The important part is understanding what you're potentially gaining—and what you're potentially giving up—before making the decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can you sell a house before it is listed
Yes. A seller may receive and accept an offer before the home is broadly marketed, subject to applicable brokerage, MLS and contractual requirements. - What does off-market mean in real estate?
Generally, an off-market property is being sold without being broadly advertised through the traditional public listing process. - Is selling off-market a good idea?
It can be. Privacy, convenience, timing and strong offer terms can make an off-market sale attractive. But sellers should also consider what they may gain from broader market exposure. - Do off-market homes sell for less?
Not necessarily. Every property and transaction is different. The challenge is determining whether an off-market offer reflects the home's current market value without exposing it to a larger pool of buyers. - Why would a seller sell off-market?
Privacy, fewer showings, convenience, timing and certainty are common reasons. Sometimes a seller simply receives an offer that's compelling enough not to pursue the traditional listing process. - Can a Realtor sell a house without putting it on the MLS?
There are circumstances where a property can be sold without broad MLS exposure, but Realtors and brokerages must follow applicable rules, disclosures and seller instructions. - What is a Coming Soon listing?
Coming Soon generally refers to a property that is being prepared for active marketing but is not yet fully available for showings or public sale under the applicable MLS rules. - Should I accept an offer before listing my house?
Price is only part of the decision. Consider the terms, contingencies, timing, likelihood of closing and how the offer compares with what your home could reasonably command on the open market. - How do I know what my home is worth before accepting an off-market offer?
Look beyond an automated estimate. Recent comparable sales, current competing listings, condition, location, buyer demand and the specific features of your home all matter. - Is it better to sell privately or expose my home to the full market?
Neither is automatically better. The right strategy depends on your home, your priorities and the current market. The goal isn't simply to get your house sold. It's to understand your options well enough to choose the strategy that makes the most sense for you.
Thinking About Selling in Birmingham or Bloomfield Hills?
Before deciding how to sell, I think it's important to understand all of your options.
Sometimes the right buyer is already looking for your home. Sometimes the smartest strategy is to bring it to the full market and let buyers compete.
My job is to help you understand the difference.
Kathy Remski
REALTOR® | @properties REMI | Christie’s International Real Estate
Luxury at every price point.
Stay Connected
Website: kathyremski.com
Instagram: @kathyremski
Facebook: Kathy Remski Real Estate
YouTube: @kathleenremski
